Sunday, February 2, 2014

The world's worst airport, my nightmare in Manila

We all have nightmare stories of getting through airports, hectic experiences of mind rending stress.  Tales of time sensitive terror, not knowing if it will take one minutes or hours to check bags and pass through security.  Before last week my worst airport experience was in Paris.  However, after trying to escape the Philipines after two weeks in Boracay I can honestly say:

Manila's airport is the worst airport I have ever experienced in my life.
I pray I never encounter it again.


So here's what happened....

After our vacation in Boracay my friends and I were eager to get home.  Though we had suffered long layovers and delays little had gone contrary to plan... until Manila.  Flying into Manila we claimed our baggage after arriving late on an Air Asia Zest flight.  To our joy, we discovered Manila possessed a free airport transfer service from various terminals for passengers with connecting flights.  A service we were eager to employ, given we had reached the end of our vacation fund (Previously, we'd had to pay over 1,000 pesos to get from one terminal to another).  I myself was down to my last 50 pesos (equivalent to about 1.05 USD).  We spoke with the dispatcher there and was informed our connecting flight was in Terminal 1.

After waiting a bit for the bus to arrive we were hurried onto the transport bus labeled "Terminal 1/3" to take us from where we'd landed in Terminal 3 to our connecting flight.  To our confusion, we were taken to Terminal 4, where we were informed our bus would not take us to Terminal 1.  After an exasperated conversation, the driver begrudingly agreed to take us to Terminal 1.  We eagerly rode there with a few other displaced passengers for a roundabout ride to Terminal 1.  At Terminal 1 we happily disembarked to find our flight.  However, we were stopped by security before entering the building and asked for our boarding passes.  The guards were rather confused that we did not already possess boarding passes despite the fact that we still needed to find the Air Asia desk (which was housed in a terminal building).  After another esasperated conversation, we discovered we'd been misinformed and were redirected to Terminal 4.
We slogged our way back to the free transport service to have an accusatory conversation witht the dispatcher there who was reluctant to help us.  After snidely inquiring why we came to Terminal 1 when our flight is in Terminal 4, my friend was forced to raise his voice to inform him we were not from Manila and could only go where we were told to go.  The dispatcher folded instantly under the pressure and let us onto the bus.  Wearily we waited as other misdirected passengers were taken to Terminal 4.

Finally arriving at our gateway to salvation, we climbed to the departures desk on the 4th floor.  Happily navigating to the Air Asia desk we joyfully claimed our tickets back to Korea.  This simple transfer between terminals had taken the better part of two hours!

However, our joy was short lived.  For as soon as we checked our bags and claimed our tickets were were halted before immigration by none other than a 550 Peso terminal fee.

That's right, only AFTER having claimed tickets already paid for does the Manila airport demand you pay an additonal fee to use it's airport.

My friend Daniel right cried out in indignation, "How much is it going to cost me to leave this country!?"
Having already been reduced to 50 Pesos by other Terminal fees and charges along the way, I was also indignant for being nickel and dimed at every transit turn on our journy home.  Thankfully, I still carried an emergency $20 in my wallet that could cover the fee.  Unfortunately, they could not give me change in USD despite having accepted it as payment.  I was able to use some of the change in pesos to help my friends through the toll gate into immigration.
At immigration we found it empty, devoid of exit forms and more importantly, pens.
Every immigration form must be filled out in ink.  Yet, in spite of charging each passenger an additional fee to use the terminal, they can't supply those passengers with pens to properly fill out their forms to leave.
Why?????

Thankfully, I had a pen hidden in the bottom of my bag or else my friends and I may have been forever trapped in transit limbo at Manila's airport.

Once slipping past immigration, we managed to find our gate with a few minutes to spare.  Had our flight not been delayed more than two hours, we'd never have made it.
I have never been so happy to cram myself onto a plane.

In summary here are the faults I've found in my experience at Manila's airport:
-The entire airport is one inconvienent tourist trap.  Each terminal is separated and passengers are ushered to take local taxis with substantial fees to get to their flights.  Those who take free transit services are often faced with delays and inconvience found in no other airport facility I've ever encounterd.
-The right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing.  Nearly every employee encountered in the Manila airport gave us contradictory information.  Be it the location of our flight, the flight time, and how to get there.  I have never seen an airport staff so inept or inefficient.
-Here, the customer is always wrong.  Everywhere we turned to try and get to where we needed to go we were halted by security guards, dispatchers, and drivers who blamed us for going to the wrong terminals!  Nevermind that it was their employees that misdirected us in the first place!
-"You're foreign! Give us your money!" Terminal fees are everywhere in the Philipines and I can understand why they exist, and exist only for foreigners.  As tourists, we are there to stimulate their economy, and they facitiltate the maintence of structures by charging tourists extra to use them.  However, when it comes to an international airport, where customers arrange and purchase services ahead of time, sneaking in addtional fees for terminal use is underhanded at best (especially for such horrible service).  Souldn't the cost of using an airport be met by the airlines who operate there?  Or as a customer am I expected to believe the airport doesn't get a cut of my ticket price to use the airport?  It just seems that everywhere your turn in Manila's airport you're met with someone trying to milk you for every peso you possess before letting you leave.

They say "alls well that ends well," and ending an otherwise pleasant vacation by leaving through Manila was as awful as putting my hand through a meat grinder.  I can honestly say that it completely sapped me of any desire to ever return to the Philipines, if not actively avoid it in the future.

I don't write this to say the Philipines is a bad place, it isn't.  It's an incredibly beautiful place and can be a relaxing place to vacation.  Yet, my god, Manila airport is far and away the worst airport I've ever experienced.

Hopefully, you never have to yourself.

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

First fist-fight

I've imagined fights lots of times.  As a writer I envision how these scenarios would go down as exhilirating action sequences, and as a teacher I consider how to mediate them.  Yet, for all my imagination, I could never have anticipated it happening as it did.
I work in a connected classroom.  My main co-teacher and I share adjacent rooms connected by a set of glass double doors.  While working at my computer nearby, I heard two kids come crashing into those glass doors.  The doors swing freely and often bump into the whiteboard I keep in front of it.  I use this board to give space between classrooms and provide a barrier to keep kids from being distracted by activities in my colleague's room.  It's not uncommon for kids to peer into my room or even push open the doors to sneak around my whiteboard.  However, when kids push hard it makes a loud crash.
The crash drew my attention, and the average "YA!" is often all it takes to show students my displeasure and send them on their way.  Yet, as I saw two sixth grade boys grappling each other I knew this was different.  I jumped from my desk and pushed into my co-teacher's room.  She was absent between classes as she often attends the teacher's meeting in the passing period between 10:20-10:40.  I quickly stepped up to the boys and began pushing them apart.
It's not easy separating two boys who have each other by the shoulders, pushing and punching at each other's faces.  But I shoved anyway and got between them.  I told the one nearest the door to leave and kept the other behind.  This boy promptly broke into tears and the other three kids in the class were deathly quiet. I pulled the boy into my class and sat him down to cool off.  I had to pull out the student photos to make sure I got his name and his combattant's name.  Which I used to do the only thing I could do, tell my co-teacher in a email what had happened.
After 10 minutes or so, my co-teacher had returned to her class and replied with a "Thank you" email.  The boy I held had stopped crying and cooled off so I sent him back to class.
That was 15 minutes ago.
I honestly still feel a bit shaken by the experience and I realize so many things about fighting that  I never knew before.
1. Fighting is messy, awkward, and unsettling.  The boys were pushing each other and struggling to keep standing.  They only managed to throw punches as I stepped between them, reaching over me.  Yet, most unsettling is how no other kids made move to stop it.  They just watched and stood silent.
2. Mediating fights is not empowering in any way.  I was practically invisible to them until I had physically separated them.  They didn't seem to hear my voice, or acknowledge I was there at all.
3. The presence of violence stirs up a myriad of emotions, many of which I had not anticipated.  I always imagined an actual fight would cause me to get angry and loud, but I didn't.  I could feel the excitement of the situation in my chest and I acted accordingly, but I wasn't angry or loud.  I was calm, even tempered and not aggressive.
Rethinking it now I see how I could have been more forceful in pulling those boys apart, perhaps preventing some punches from landing, but I didn't.  I acted solely on instinct and it was calm and direct.  I suppose that's a good thing, but I sit here with a looming sense of insecurity and deep concern.  Not for my well being, these kids couldn't physically hurt me.  Yet, I'm bothered that they do fight in my co-teacher's empty classroom with me next door.  I can't help but wonder, has this happened before?  Even more unsettling is the realization that I have no way of reconciling this event because I can't communicate how it errupted.  I know kids say awful things to each other and often turn to slaps and shoves, Korean kids are extremely physical in their affections and slights.  Yet, there is always a present playfulness, one that was obviously devoid in this event.
In the end I suppose I hate that I have no way of protecting my students from themselves, let alone each other.  I have no way of mentoring them into better ways of handling anger or conflict.  I have only one other teacher I can consult on such conflict because I don't speak much Korean.  All thse these realities are crushingly apparent and I feel sad, shaken, disempowered.  More and more, I realize elementary school is about cultivating sociable behaviors and conflict resolution.  The kind of skills that make us functional members of the adult populace.  The more I realize the importance of character development in young kids the less I feel I have to offer them.  It's not a good feeling.
Hopefully, there will not be any more fights in school.  Hopefully, these boys will settle their differences and get along in a school that's too small for kids to avoid each other.  Hopefully, they'll all get along and just enjoy being kids.
But I've learned optimism is not often affirmed in such matters....

Friday, November 29, 2013

Teaching the game...

I'm certainly not the first person to say life is a game.  It is in many ways, not simply in the manner in which life is playful and beautiful, but in how we interact with each other.  We are all playing games with one another, many of them with particular rules.  Some rules are implicit, others explicit, and our ability to play by and bend the rules of these games is what makes up our social lives.  The games we play are games of etiquette, communication, affection, and attention.  Their rules tell us who we say "hello" to and how we respond to the question "how are you?"  They reinforce our relationships, be they friendships, love affairs, or family, guiding us in how to act and react.

I've come to see teaching as a misunderstood game, or perhaps, misperceived.

Mainly, because what mass education does isn't necessarily what we think it does.  Many of us come to school thinking of it as a place to acquire academic knowledge, but it isn't.  Schools (at least until university) are not simply places of academic development, they are centers of social reinforcement.

Schools teach people how to interact with their society.  They set standards (at a very young age) about what it is to be a good citizen.

When I started as a teacher, I considered my position as an academic one.  I was to nurture and impart knowledge upon learners, academic and practical communication skills.  However, now I'm coming to realize that academia is another social game.  It has it's unique rules, skills, and structure.  We are trained in high school how to play the academic game, how to study, read, and write research papers.  How to receive research tasks and carry them out independently of moment to moment guidance.  If we can demonstrate proficiency at this game, we graduate and are given the option to continue playing academia in higher education.  It is a game I admittedly enjoy, but a game nonetheless and it's rules and skills do not always apply outside it's walls.

These days I spend a great deal of time teaching young students.  Kids who are still learning the ropes when it comes to the game of society.  I find that my greatest trials as a teacher are not teaching, but enforcing the necessary behavior to teach in a classroom environment.  This is a unique challenge as a foreign teacher because the standards of behavior in class are quite different when it comes to Korea and the US.  Furthermore, my students' perceptions of me as a foreign teacher also contribute an enormous amount to their own conceptions regarding appropriate behavior.  Because I'm a foreigner the norms I expect in a classroom are not the same for Koreans.
For example: in the US, it is expected that when the bell rings, class begins.  You are expected to be in your seats and ready to start a lesson.  In Korea, students tend to be rushing to class after the bell rings.  It's not uncommon for students to arrive in class anywhere from five minutes before the bell to five minutes after the bell!  Yet, this is acceptable, and normal in the classes I've attended and taught in this country.  Is this one of the reasons many Koreans are notorious for being fashionably late?  I'm not sure, but it is curious to ponder.

I have never received any formal training as a teacher.  What I have learned I've learned on the job and from online courses in teaching.  Though classroom management is an important topic, I have yet to really learn of a teaching course that considers the cultural implications of teaching kids to behave in a classroom.  Being in education my imagination is inherently drawn to consider educational structure, method, and reform.  I wonder if we are fooling ourselves about the aims of state sanctioned education.  Academic skills are what we want to impart on our students, it's these subjects that teachers get passionate about and invest themselves in teaching.  However, what schools do (or implicitly aim to do) is not make passionate learners, but functional citizens.
I'm still in a personal debate about this.  I wonder if it would be better if we reevaluated our education system to explicitly teach students and parents about it's goals to make children into citizens, or if it should simply focus on academic skills.  Because if we ignore the moralizing aspect of our education system we are in tacit compliance to the values it passes to children with no dialog about what those values are and how they are transmitted into young minds.  Similarly, it cripples teachers with an enormous social responsibility that they are not necessarily trained to consider or carry out.  Furthermore it creates a biased standard for which the success of schools is based.  Schools are evaluated upon the testable academic ability of its students, not upon their ability to be good citizens.  Yet, what are the measurable traits of a functional citizen?  Political participation? Stable economic standing with a strong work ethic?  Clean criminal record? Are good students the kids who have strong academic skills, or simply the one's who have learned to play the game?  Both?
It's worth pondering.

Being an outsider in an education system it's easier to see the socializing characteristics of public education.  I try and think back to my own experience as a student and wonder how I thought of my experience.  It's hard to dial back my thinking to remember what I was like to experience school as a child.  I wonder what kinds of behaviors my education instilled in me without really noticing it.  I have to wonder as a teacher now what kinds of behaviors my teaching is implying to my students and how that may contribute to their academic success later in life.  I can't help but feel uncomfortable about the idea of being partially responsible for the moral and social development of children.  I'm much more keen on being a source of knowledge and guidance academically.  Yet, I suppose what makes teaching such a grand adventure is discovering these unexpected aspects of its execution. I never cease to be amazed at how much I don't know about what I do for a living.  It's perplexing.  So much to learn, so much to do.